Interior Secretary Scales Back Snowmobile Use in Yellowstone National Park, Calls for More Public Comment
With a new administration in Washington, the pendulum on snowmobile use in Yellowstone National Park is swinging back towards fewer machines. Interior Secretary Ken Salazar on Thursday directed the National Park Service to follow a course that could limit recreational snowmobile use in Yellowstone to 318 machines per day for each of the next two winters.
Specifically, the Interior secretary told the Park Service to reopen the public comment period on a proposed interim winter-use plan that would cap daily snowmobile use in Yellowstone to 318 machines, and limit commercially guided snowcoach tours to 78 machines per day. If the interim plan is implemented, the secretary added, it would remain in effect for two winters while the Park Service makes another attempt at crafting a viable winter-use plan for Yellowstone and Grand Teton national parks.
Snowmobile use in Yellowstone arguably has been the most partisan and contentious issue in the entire National Park System the past decade. While the Clinton administration at the very end of its term in office moved to ban recreational snowmobile use in the park, the incoming Bush administration quickly blocked that ban and sent the issue down a prickly, and expensive, legal course. More than $10 million in environmental studies were conducted on the issue during the past decade, and all pointed to the phase-out of snowmobiles as the best environmental alternative for Yellowstone. Despite those studies and former Interior Secretary Dirk Kempthorne's pledge that science would rule the day in the National Park System, strings pulled from not just the Interior Department but as high up as former Vice President Cheney's office handcuffed the Park Service.
The Park Service under the Bush administration continually opted not to go with the environmentally preferable alternative. In November 2007, after the latest round of studies, the agency decided to allow up to 540 snowmobiles and 83 snowcoaches into the park on a daily basis. But the predicted legal challenges to that decision resulted in a federal judge scolding the agency last September for ignoring science and running from its conservation mission.
In his 63-page ruling, which was stinging at times in its criticism of the Park Service's interpretation of its own Organic Act, U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan held that while the Organic Act does call for public enjoyment of the national parks, "(T)his is not blanket permission to have fun in the parks in any way the NPS sees fit."
"As plaintiffs articulated at the hearing, the 'enjoyment' referenced in the Organic Act is not enjoyment for its own sake, or even enjoyment of the parks generally, but rather the enjoyment of 'the scenery and natural and historic objects and wild life' in the parks in a manner that will allow future generations to enjoy them as well," wrote Judge Sullivan. "NPS cannot circumvent this limitation through conclusory declarations that certain adverse impacts are acceptable, without explaining why those impacts are necessary and appropriate to fulfill the purposes of the park."
Furthermore, he noted, "According to NPS's own data the (winter-use plan) will increase air pollution, exceed the use levels recommended by NPS biologists to protect wildlife, and cause major adverse impacts to the natural soundscape in Yellowstone. Despite this, NPS found that the plan's impacts are wholly 'acceptable,' and utterly fails to explain this incongruous conclusion."
While Judge Sullivan tossed that winter-use plan, thus seemingly leading the Park Service back to the drawing board, from which it quickly proposed the interim rule of 318 snowmobiles and 78 snowcoaches per day, another federal judge, Clarence Brimmer in Wyoming, trumped his Washington, D.C., colleague. While Judge Brimmer noted that he couldn't overrule his cross-country colleague, he could direct the Park Service to revert to 2004 winter-use regulations if it couldn't come up with a new rule before the 2008-2009 winter season began. That opened the door for the Park Service to halt work on the interim rule and turn back the hands of time to 2004, when as many as 720 snowmobiles were allowed into the park on a daily basis.
Which brings us to Thursday's announcement by Interior Secretary Salazar.
“The proposed rule would allow continued access to the park in winter while ensuring the protection of this national treasure and its wildlife while we develop a new long-term plan for winter use in the park,” the secretary said, seemingly overlooking a report by Park Service wildlife biologists that no more than 250 snowmobiles a day should be allowed into Yellowstone to protect the wildlife.
Here are the latest details: The interim proposed rule would allow up to 318 commercially guided, Best Available Technology snowmobiles, and up to 78 commercially guided snowcoaches per day in Yellowstone, through the 2010-2011 winter season. It would also govern long-term snowmobile access in Grand Teton and the John D. Rockefeller, Jr. Memorial Parkway, including access along Grassy Lake Road, and on Jackson Lake for licensed anglers.
The proposed rule and an electronic form to submit written comments are available on the Internet at http://www.regulations.gov/search/index.jsp. The public can find the proposed rule by searching the “Documents Open For Public Comment” and selecting the National Park Service as the agency.
Written comments may be submitted through the above cited web site, in person, or by mail. Comments will not be accepted by phone, fax, or e-mail. All public comments on the proposed rule must be received or postmarked by midnight, Eastern Time, September 8, 2009.
The National Park Service intends to analyze the comments submitted last fall and during the next 45 days before making a decision on the proposed interim winter use plan. Depending on this process, NPS is planning to issue a final rule to implement the decision on or before November 15, 2009.