You are here

Traveler's View: Would You Rather Have Wi-Fi Or Water During Your National Park Vacation?

Share

Why does the National Park Service seem to be more interested in solving Wi-Fi connectivity in the parks than providing water?/NPS, David Restivo photo to illustrate that cell reception and WiFi connectivity is very limited in Glacier National Park

If all goes well, you'll be able to pick up high-speed Internet in all national parks by 2018. Finding a water-filling station? Well, probably not.

In a strategy that seems strange, the Park Service is hell-bent to wire the National Park System but isn't in quite the same hurry to have water-filling stations available for visitors to quench their thirst.

Why the emphasis on Wi-Fi? Shane Compton, the Park Service's chief information officer, says part of it is to provide more park information to visitors. The other part is so they can bring their work with them to the park.

"I can tell you the complaints we get when somebody goes in to a park and finds a hotel doesn’t have high-speed Wi-Fi so they can do their work while they are on vacation," Mr. Compton told Federal News Radio back in December. "It’s an expectation now so IT has to make sure it’s there.”

There once was an expectation that the Park Service would see water-filling stations in at least 75 percent of the visitor facilities across the park system by this year. But that goal, noted in the agency's Green Parks Plan in 2010, was watered down the following year by Park Service Director Jon Jarvis to make water-filling stations "optional" for park superintendents.

As we noted Sunday, since the water-filling goal, which has transformed into an aspiration, was announced in 2010, just 22 parks have moved in that direction. There currently is no concerted push equal to the Wi-Fi drive to ban disposable plastic bottles and provide water-filling stations, though the Park Service has an "ultimate goal is to reduce the waste of disposable plastic water bottles as much as possible," spokesman Jeremy Barnum told the Traveler last week.

Of course, banning disposable water bottles won't entirely solve the problem with plastic litter in the parks. As long as soda and other flavored drinks continue to be sold in the parks in plastic containers, and as long as visitors tote cases of bottled water into the parks, there will be litter.

But the Park Service's focus on Wi-Fi, and apparent disinterest in the availability of water for visitors, is peculiar. On one hand, the agency is supportive of technology that in many ways can be disruptive to the national park experience, and yet on the other it seems to be giving short shrift to a key aspect of its Healthy Parks, Healthy People program; that is, enabling visitors to avoid dehydration on their park outings.

Now, this is not to diminish the value of having Internet access in the parks. NPS.gov has endless reams of content that can help interpret the parks to visitors. (Although, an experienced, outgoing interpretive ranger can do a much, much better job, and bookstores in the parks overflow with interpretive volumes!) So if parks must be wired, provide it in visitor centers, restaurants, and lodgings.

But shouldn't there be an equal, or even greater, interest in providing water to those visitors? We think so.

Comments

"since the water-filling goal, which has transformed into an aspiration"

Bottled water and soda is a profit center for the Park Service. Why would they want to give this up for the good of the visitors and the enviroment......


I can do without the internet for a few days. I can't do without water. But, I typically carry plenty of my own in refillable gallon jugs...

I don't think I have been in a national park that didn't have a water fountain. Yes, a little awkward to fill my bottle, but works in a pinch.


That is just sick, needing wi-fi to enjoy the outdoors


profit?  How exactly?  Water and soda is sold by concessionaires, not the park.


How about WIFI for the benefit of the employees in National Parks?  We all seem to do business that way.


I can see wifi being provided at park headquarters, park residences, visitor centers, and perhaps at concession lodges, but that's it.  Parks should be places where one can escape the rapid pace of the electronic world.  The only valid use of a smart phone at an overlook should be for taking photos, not instantly posting such photos to social media, or reading e-mail.  The NPS says that wifi needs to be provided in our parks so that kids will come to the parks.  Nonsense!  I believe that the principal reasons why kids don't come to the parks is that their parents don't come to the parks.  The reasons why parents don't come to the parks is (a) lack of financial resources, (b) an increase in the number of families without resident fathers, and perhaps most importantly (c) lack of access to free time. I grew up in the San Francisco Bay Area.  When I first visited Yosemite, it was because my parents took me to Yosemite.  I loved it at first sight.


So they're fast-tracking Wi-fi in the National Parks, but falling behind their goals on reducing unnecessary waste from plastic bottles.  Sounds like par for the course.  I appreciate PEER and others who are promoting the water refill stations and plastic water bottle bans.  Besides the litter and solid waste, water in those non-refillable containers has not been shown to be an improvement over most tap water.


Parks should be places where one can escape the rapid pace of the electronic world.  The only valid use of a smart phone at an overlook should be for taking photos, not instantly posting such photos to social media, or reading e-mail.

That is how you want to enjoy the park but what gives you the right to dictate how others enjoy the park?


Add comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

The Essential RVing Guide

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

The National Parks RVing Guide, aka the Essential RVing Guide To The National Parks, is the definitive guide for RVers seeking information on campgrounds in the National Park System where they can park their rigs. It's available for free for both iPhones and Android models.

This app is packed with RVing specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 parks.

You'll also find stories about RVing in the parks, some tips if you've just recently turned into an RVer, and some planning suggestions. A bonus that wasn't in the previous eBook or PDF versions of this guide are feeds of Traveler content: you'll find our latest stories as well as our most recent podcasts just a click away.

So whether you have an iPhone or an Android, download this app and start exploring the campgrounds in the National Park System where you can park your rig.