Back in 2011, the last time there were fatal maulings in Yellowstone, a grizzly sow was put down after two attacks. In the first, park officials let her live as they considered her actions in a mauling as defensive. But two months later she was tied to the partial consumption of another hiker who had been fatally mauled.
Aug 13th - 00:09am |
The clearest account of what happened will be determined from what physical evidence could be reasonably collected. Hopefully the flood of emotions, speculation, and sensationalized media stories, will not erode the decision making process regarding any bear that may be proven to be involved in this unfortunate incident.
Aug 13th - 00:03am |
First off, it is a tragedy that this man lost his life in the park he obviously loved. My heart goes out to his family and friends.
We attended the Perseid Meteor Shower Party last night and enjoyed it very much. I'm glad we attended Greg Redfern's presentation before venturing out. It was very interesting and informative. Thanks for the red film we received from the park employees. How thoughtful! We wished everyone had gotten one of these--many flashlights out there in the field, unfortunately, with out it.
As I sit here listening to the sound of my neighbors riding mower, the others weed trimmer, and the occasional truck and Harley rumbling past my house I love this idea. Sound can travel so far I'm not sure there is a place in the lower 48 to escape the sounds of man these days. Isle Royale and perhaps a few places in the boundary waters?
Aug 12th - 17:12pm |
Sound studies are good and the noise from many motorcycles is indeed a problem but there is a far larger problem associated with overcrowding. When my wife and I visited the Grand Tetons in 1975 it was quite peaceful. We particularly enjoyed the solitude during our walk around Jenny Lake. Last week we went back to visit the area again, perhaps for old times sake.
When we start valuing our public lands one tenth as much as we value our military, we might have a chance at improving conditions at all the National Parks, heritage sites, and historical sites. As it stands, the DOD budget is around $496 billion; the DOI budget: $12 billion. Unfortunately, congress is still working on cutting the latter and boosting the former.
And while I'm feeling creative, I've got this idea for a hiking bear canister which would be required any time you take a hike in bear country. Much like those for food but designed to protect the hiker and end the need to euthanize problem bears. A large human sized polycarbonate barrel with leg and neck holes.
Well, I never imagined drivers would be forced to wear seat belts, kids would have to wear helmets to ride a bike, skiers needed helmets, and monkey bars were too dangerous so why am I surprised to read hikers are encouraged to wear helmets. I am in the process of patenting my shower helmet which can also be worn in your rocking chair. Anyone want to invest?
Aug 12th - 11:04am |
How do you hike parallel when the trail is a foot wide? You stay on the trail and be vigilant about your surroundings.
Aug 12th - 10:53am |
What does it mean to "hike parallel to one another" and how does that prevent accidents such as this one?
Comparing Biscayne to Big Cypress is an apples to oranges comparison and unfair to the NPS staff & superintendents at BiCy. As a National Preserve, Big Cypress falls under a wildly different mandate than National Parks such as Biscayne.
Once again we are not talking about 1 or 2 disabled persons were talking about a group of people touring the park on segways hookah perfectly walk easy enough all of you people who have disabled Parkers stop being so sensitive or not trying to take away your Segway
Don't kill the bear. Humans are not the owners of the planet.
Aug 12th - 01:29am |
I'm totally against killing this bear.....she was probably protecting her cub.....did you ever think he got to close and didn't even know they were there??
Aug 11th - 23:39pm |
Reminds me of what a South Dakota Park Ranger told me when I asked why they didn't seem to have bears. "They're way too dangerous," he said."people killed 'em off for good reason - so they could be safe outside and their kids wouldn't get eaten!" We laughed and he was grinning and said it half-jokingly - but there was some wisdom there. Couldn't settle the west with grizz chasing them!
Aug 11th - 18:23pm |
It seems that Mr Crosby's death, while tragic, was also due his own negligence. Running early morning in a known bear habitat, without a moneymaker or bear spray? I learned my lesson a few years ago, running through a residential neighborhood in Tahoe of all places. There were warning signs posted everywhere but I thought, surely not.
Aug 11th - 15:19pm |
We have visited many of our National Parks and have loved every one. Glacier, Yellowstone and Denali are our favorites because of the grizzlies that live there. We love seeing them BUT we do everything we can to stay safe. I am so sorry for Mr. Crosby and his family. This was a terrible accident. However the sow seems to have been doing what mama bears do in protecting her baby.
Aug 11th - 15:19pm |
8 JULY 2011
Yellowstone National Park authorities will not try to capture a female grizzly that killed a hiker because the bear was trying to defend its cubs when it was surprised by the man.
Aug 11th - 14:25pm |
We have been going to YNP for years. It is a wild place, and many seem to not care about the dangers to themselves or the animals. The park rangers tell you to hike in groups, carry bear spray, stay on the trails and make noise. He was jogging alone, without bear spray & off the trails - he was doing it all wrong. I am tired of bears being killed when they are doing what bears do.
Aug 11th - 13:08pm |
The man did nothing wrong.
The bear did nothing wrong.
Aug 11th - 12:57pm |
I feel sorry for this poor man and his family but somehow it's exhilirationg to think there are still places left where a grizzly can kill and eat you if you are not careful.Sorry if that offends anyone.....
Aug 11th - 10:02am |
Anonymous in SC
Why not relocate the bear and cub to another national park.....perhaps several states away.
As I used to remind my visitors in Yosemite, by far more people die on their way to the national parks than have the privilege of dying in them. Unfortunately, the visitors just don't quite see things that way--or the lawyers who back them up. But yes. It's time to start closing these parks in sequence and giving the wildlife a rest.
Aug 10th - 17:25pm |
I agree with "Anonymous " comments! ! Sad but I true !!!
Why on earth are they punishing the bear for being a bear? Unless the hiker was incapable of reading he knew that he was hiking in bear country. Eugenics is a beautiful evolutionary process and some lucky grizzly bear was able to participate in the process. Killing a bear because its genetically programmed to kill is pure unadulterated nonsense!
If it were not for humans this bear and her cub would still be safe and free. Thinking that a visitor management program aimed at minimizing human-bear interactions etc., would do more good than any grizzly bear management program.
Aug 10th - 16:05pm |
The bear is extremely dangerous and must be destroyed as the article notes.
The remains of Edwin Birch were identified by the local medical examiner last week after being discovered near the Fryingpan Glacier above Panhandle Gap. Rest in peace.http://www.thenewstribune.com/news/local/article29887330.html
Thinking about what is needed in the national park system in terms of it being "too small" or how many more acres should be added or what it costs to manage it is misleading and misses the important point. What happens to the system in the future must be based on values. We should never stop adding areas that possess the values that are worth protecting for future generations.
Anyone think present actions on the borders with millions of undocumented and documented immigrants coming into the country is a good thing and how Parks and other wild lands will be effected? Seemingly the same folks in DC that are allowing it also are making more National Monuments. Is that the payoff? Just looking at it in the big picture. Major trouble in River City I am thinking.
Aug 10th - 21:50pm |
I retired in 2011 after more than 35 years in the National Park Service. I enjoyed all of my 13 assignments, ranging from seasonal park aid to park superintendent. However, the most interesting year was 1999 when I was the 10th Bevinetto Congressional Fellow assigned to the U.S. Senate Energy and National Resources Committee, National Parks Subcommittee.
Alfred--As Bob Dylan sang, "I'll let you be in my dream if I can be in yours."
Harry--Who's in charge of the slimming down process? The historians? The biologists? The Regional Directors? Mitch McConnell? And the NPS has been through zero-based budgeting. Did it help the first time?
When I worked as a park ranger-naturalist at Crater Lake, Zion, and Yosemite, I used to spend a lot of time worrying about this very question. I was much concerned that the economics of industrial tourism and outdoor recreation was influencing the character of the NPS much more than its mission to preserve and protect.