Mt. Rainier or Olympics NP?

My boyfriend and I are planning to go to Seattle and we have one day for exploring a national park, so the question is - Mt. Rainier or Olympics? Could anyone advise us on which NP is best for a one-day trip from Seattle?

Best regards,
Sine

I'm sorry WoJo's experience

I'm sorry WoJo's experience fell short of expectations. There's not much to do inside snowy Mt. Rainier NP at
this time of year for someone not interested in climbing, skiing or snowshoeing. I'd agree that the Park
concessions leave a lot to be desired, perhaps because the local operation by Guest Services Inc. is largely
a tax write-off for the company that runs the government cafeterias in Washington D.C. They've even recently
discontinued their traditional ski/snowshoe lessons and guided trips.

I'd also agree that Ashford is mostly a collection of shacks and mobiles, but it's far less tacky than a lot of National Park gateway communities. Many local residents are retirees and refugees from our increasingly ugly and unaffordable cities. Climate change is killing lots of local trees; the chain saws are busy in the Spring because firewood needs to season at least six months to be ready for the long, hard winters. Many people here keep dogs because law enforcement response time is at least one hour. There are worse things than noisy chainsaws and barking dogs. Locals have to put up with automatic weapons fire and fleets of military helicopters commuting between Tacoma's Fort Lewis and the Yakima firing range. There are also compensations like talented artists and seeing elk herds from your porch.

Rural areas are not "wilderness", few of which have steaks and fresh produce either. Despite the official designation, this 'scenic drive' National Park is not truly wilderness in my opinion. It's just too small to include winter range for many species. It's also too sliced up by the past road-building enthusiasm of National Park managers, who increasingly exclude the public from roads plowed and maintained for "administrative use". Hopefully, the Park staff didn't tell you to "go somewhere else if you don't like the way we do things". This has been the all too common experience of visitors who question this Park's policies.

The above comments are intended as explanations, not excuses. Despite all these shortcomings, I hope WoJo
returns sometime in August (perhaps September this year) and gives our nation's 5th National Park and
greatest mountain outside Alaska another chance. In early morning before the crowds arrive, it's easy to
understand why John Muir called aptly named Paradise "...the most extravagantly beautiful of all the alpine
gardens I ever beheld in all my mountain-top wanderings". Less crowded attractions like Sunrise and Chinook Pass are equally beautiful.

This year we stayed at

This year we stayed at Dancing Bear Lodge in Ashford near the Rainier National Park Longmire entrance. Every year the wilderness experience becomes less so. From our vacation house in the so called woods the jets roaring overhead day and night drowned out the wildlife, but not the neighboring chain saws that ran all day long, nor the constantly barking very large dogs on neighboring properties. The deer came through and were scared off by a neighbor walking her dog that tried to chase them. A walk down Tahoma Canyon road passed messes of crumbling structures, lots of mobile homes, and NO TRESPASS signs. I guess you need at least one on every other tree to give people the message. How unatractive I found the signs I can't express. The National Park personnel at Longmire behaved irritated by our visiting and the fact that they had to come open up the gift shop. One man actually huffed the entire time we browsed giving me the impression he wished we'd hurry up and just get going so he could get back to talking to another employee who's chat we'd interrupted. The store in Ashford has very little, no meat or fruit or vegetables. Elbe is worse. Gas is cheeper in Ashford at the one gas station there. Eatonville is about a 30 minute drive if you want to pick up fresh produce or a steak. Anyway, the constant roar of the jets was supper disapointing. A sound of the times. I keep looking for the wilderness to visit that lives up to the name. I found the Trio of Treasures vaction last year to the Olympic N Forest area Sol Duc, Quinalt and Ocean at Klaloch (sp?) friendlier people and much quieter. Montana has a great number of great quiet get aways as well. I just hate when the human created noise and dogs scare away the wild life that I go to observe.

Guess there's no much

Guess there's no much traffic here. I just found this site myself.

I assume that you already took this trip, but just in case someone else is looking for an opinion:

Olympic is about a 3 1/2 hour drive (or so)

Mt. Rainier is only 1 1/2 hours (or so)

Olympic is at least a 3 day visit with rain forest, Hurricane Ridge and tidal pool areas worth a day's exploration each

Rainier, depending on the length of the hike you take can be done in one day if you just want an introduction to the park (almost all parks really require several days to get the true taste of it)

If you are looking for a week or two or three in the area also consider:
North Cascades National Park
Oregon Caves National Monument
Mount St. Helens National Volcanic Park
Crater Lake National Park
Lava Beds National Monument