You are here

To Wire, Or Not To Wire, The National Parks, That Is The Question

Share
Alternate Text
Should the national parks have greater cellphone coverage?/PEER

Should the National Park Service work to see 4G coverage extended to as much of the National Park System as possible? Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility doesn't believe that should happen, and is behind a petition drive to have that idea spiked before we find visitors experiencing the parks in the palms of their hands, and not by using all their senses.

"Our national parks are on the cusp of being wired for streaming videos, music downloads and on-line games for visitor-subscribers to extend 4G (4th Generation) coverage into parks such as Yellowstone. These developments will allow visitors '“ particularly young people '“ to experience our parks not through their eyes but with noses buried in their electronic devices," PEER says in pushing its petition drive. 

"The proliferation of this cyber-infrastructure in our parks means more, ugly cell towers marring vistas, 'spill-over' coverage in wilderness and backcountry and the loss of solitude '“ being disconnected from the electronic tendrils of the modern world. Do not  further 'œDisney-fy' our national parks.  Disconnect the devices and reconnect with nature."

The petition is to be sent to Interior Secretary Sally Jewell. PEER hopes to get 15,000 signatures. As of mid-day Friday, it had 63. 

Comments

Wired or not, my boys are not allowed to use their mobile devices in the parks (except when hanging out in our room/cabin).


A horrible intrusion changing the whole experience by users and those around them.  A degrading effect noticed even in many very remote locations where many go to reconnect with themselves rather than technology.   So disheartening to witness. 


A couple of days ago I was in Congaree National Park. There is hardly any cell phone service there. It would have been nice, hiking on the trails, had we been able to access information about some of the plants and trees we were seeing and maybe a more in depth history of the park, while we were on the trails and taking breaks. There was one particularly giant tree I was very interested in, having never seen one that size, but I was out of luck. And the visitor center didn't provide much more information. Imagine all I could have learned while walking those trails!

The assumption that all cell/data service will be used for " streaming videos, music downloads and on-line games" is ridiculous. And if one wants to disconnect "from the electronic tendrils of the modern world" one simply has to turn off their own phone.

Having access to greater amounts of information while visiting a National Park enhances my use of the park; it doesn't diminish it. It is easier to fall in love with something when you know it. Cell/data service can provide that knowledge where the park visitor centers fail. Unless of course, one can carry a seasoned ranger with them.


More than likely that was a loblolly pine, Dahkota.  Those are very impressive in Congaree and make up most of the tallest trees.

I do use an app from the audubon bird song/identification app, and a wildflower app that I have on my phone that works when I am not connected to the internet.  They definitely aid in identifying what you are staring at, but you have to download the information before you go.   I also use the peakfinder app when i'm trying to identify some peak way out in the distance, and that's just based on GPS and doesn't require coverage.  The GPS co-located 3d terrain map apps can be more useful in plotting a route through a trail-less wilderness than a topo, especially when you get into an area and something captures your attention and you want to spend some time exploring.  But, of course it's dependent on how much battery power you have, however you can always buy batteries to take with you to keep your phone charged..  I recently used a gps map on a trip in the rockies where we went off trail quite a bit, and there were not any cell towers within many many many miles.  But the phone was very useful because it shows you exactly where you are in the trailless terrain.

I personally don't want to see towers all over our National Parks and that's one of the reasons I think wilderness act applied to parks like Yellowstone and Grand Canyon is a necessity, but on the same token I can still utilize my phone for other things, especially in regards to information. People used to have to haul 5 books, topos, etc for information that can now be stored on a little handheld device. If i'm on a long multi-day trek, I do find an occasional delight is playing a documentary that I downloaded to my phone. Plus, it's not going to be long before cell towers are a thing of the past, and satellite technology is the norm. So, I see cell towers as a temporary thing, that will be gone in 20 to 30 years. I believe the government should think very hard before they pave trails into what could be wilderness to plop towers everywhere just for "security".   And, on the same token, when it's 8:00 pm, pitch black, and youre in the wilderness, letting your little one watch stored cartoons or listen to music on an iphone in the tent isn't necessarily destroying his/her experience and those things add to their enjoyment. And it doesn't seem to affect his ability to spot EVERY little thing on a trail.  So, on the same token, I don't necessarily jive with the philosphical beliefs of the "purists". I think it adds to the fun factor of kids to be able to relax and play a game in a tent, especially if you are on a multi-day excursion where there is some down time.  And you don't have to be "wired" to experience those things..


Having taken many families and individuals into one of the 7 Natural Wonders of the World and seen the very positive transformations that kids (and adults) experience connecting to real as opposed to virtual, this is a very bad idea, seriously! Very addictive this technology and goes against everything these Parks have meant to generations before. NPS is selling their soul if they let this happen in the National Parks any farther than it already has. We all need more real engagement and not this BS virtual, I believe.


Gary, it wasn't the loblolly, though the ones there are impressive; this was a deciduous tree, with ovoid serrated leaves, a grayish trunk.

I'm not saying that towers and access have to extend deep into the wilderness - in fact, I would be completely against that. However, I see no reason for there not to be access in the front country areas, within a mile or two of the roads and visitor centers, where 95% of visitors go. The visitor centers provide some information but it is generally soundbites. I wish for more detailed information. I would talk to an interpretive ranger to get that information but, in parks such as GSMNP, they are woefully understaffed.


Lots of factors influence our opinions on this subject, but there's little doubt cell phones have become a very big deal for many people today. A term has even been coined for the fear of being out of contact by cell phone. It's called "nomophobia" (short for "no-mobile-phone phobia"), and some researchers now claim it's gotten so prevalent that "Fear of not having a working cell phone should be added to psychiatry’s diagnostic manual." 

This article about "smartphone addiction" says, "In a national survey conducted  in the fall of 2013, 63% of respondents said they check their phone for messages or calls once an hour, while 9% said they checked their phone every five minutes. An additional 63% said they would be upset if they left home without their smartphone. Many would return home to retrieve it, even if they're out on just a quick trip to the store." 

Whether or not we like the idea of expanded cell service, information such as the above suggests it will be a tough battle for the NPS to resist pressure to expand wireless service into more and more areas. Today's Traveler article about a possible project at Yellowstone is likely just the first of many such proposals.


My wife takes hikes in nearby bear country several times a week. She thinks it is a nuisance when I remind her, but I do ask her to carry her phone, just like you put a water bottle or basic first aid supplies in your pack. She is definitely __not__ rocking out to the oldies out there and it disturbs no one for her to have 911 availability.


Add comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

The Essential RVing Guide

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

The National Parks RVing Guide, aka the Essential RVing Guide To The National Parks, is the definitive guide for RVers seeking information on campgrounds in the National Park System where they can park their rigs. It's available for free for both iPhones and Android models.

This app is packed with RVing specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 parks.

You'll also find stories about RVing in the parks, some tips if you've just recently turned into an RVer, and some planning suggestions. A bonus that wasn't in the previous eBook or PDF versions of this guide are feeds of Traveler content: you'll find our latest stories as well as our most recent podcasts just a click away.

So whether you have an iPhone or an Android, download this app and start exploring the campgrounds in the National Park System where you can park your rig.