A Tough Week for Hikers and Mule Riders at Grand Canyon National Park

Short haul rescue at Grand Canyon. NPS photo.

Park Paramedic Bonnie Taylor with the patient during short-haul rescue operation for the injured hiker on April 28, 2008. NPS photo.

It's been a tough week or so for hikers, mule riders and rescue teams at Grand Canyon National Park. During a 6-day span, a hiker fell off a trail and a rider was injured in an accident on a mule trip. Both required rescue via a park helicopter.

On April 28, 2009, a 47 year-old Ohio man headed down the Grandview Trail, just east of the park's South Rim Village. His intended destination was Cottonwood Creek, a backcountry camping area below the South Rim. According to a park report, at about 3:20 p.m.

The man and his hiking companions were several hundred feet down the trail when he stopped to peer over the edge and lost his balance.
A visitor at the Grandview Trailhead heard calls for help and called Grand Canyon Regional Communications Center. Park rangers responded and found the man lying injured on the trail.

Because of the steep terrain and difficult switchbacks, and for the safety of the patient, rangers called for the park helicopter and extricated the man using a short-haul operation. The procedure normally involves a rescuer on a fixed line, extended below a helicopter that is flown into the rescue site. The rescuer then attaches the patient, via a Bauman bag, and flies with them to a safe location – in this case, the parking lot at Grandview Overlook.

Once at the parking lot the patient was stabilized and transported by ground ambulance to the South Rim Helibase. From there he was transported by Classic Life Guard to the Flagstaff Medical Center to be treated for life-threatening injuries.

Approximately 20 people from the National Park Service were involved in the rescue. Personnel from the park’s emergency services, interpretation, wildland fire and aviation, and law enforcement divisions, and park volunteers all responded to the accident scene and provided assistance.

On May 4, 2009, a 66-year-old woman was injured on May 4, 2009, when the mule she was riding lost its footing, fell, and then rolled over the woman.

At approximately 9:00 a.m. the park's Dispatch Center received a radio call from a mule wrangler about the incident. According to a park report,

The accident occurred approximately 2 ½ miles below the rim on the Bright Angel Trail. The mule and its passenger were part of two concessioner mule strings that were en route to Phantom Ranch for an overnight stay. The mule concession is operated by Xanterra South Rim, LLC.

Two National Park Service paramedics were flown to the accident scene and stabilized the patient before extricating her using a short-haul operation—the same technique used in the hiker's rescue. In this case, the victim was flown to the South Rim Helibase, and then transferred to the Flagstaff Medical Center by Classic Life Guard.
Approximately 12 people from the National Park Service were involved in the rescue operation. They were assisted by Xanterra mule wranglers and visitors on the trail.

During helicopter operations, the Bright Angel Trail was closed for approximately 1 hour.

Information on the extent of the woman's injuries was not available from the park or the hospital.

Providers and fans of the mule trips point out that accidents involving those trips are extremely rare. According to the 2001 edition of the book, Over the Edge: Death in Grand Canyon, by Michael P. Ghiglieri and Thomas M. Myers,

the mule skinners running tourists down the Bright Angel Trail to Phantom Ranch hold an apparently perfect record: No client among the half million or so taken has been killed while riding a mule.

Ghiglieri and Myers report that the only fatal accident involving a mule train at the park occurred on Bright Angel Trail in 1951, and it involved a mule skinner for the former concessioner, the Fred Harvey Company, not a visitor.

Michael F. Anderson's Polishing the Jewel: An Administrative History of Grand Canyon National Park notes that mule rides into the canyon predate the establishment of the park in 1919. In the 1880s John Hance ... "improved a Havasupai trail to the Tonto Platform, and launched a small tourist venture, offering tents beside his cabin, simple meals, and mule trips."

Today's concessioner-operated trips trace their roots to operations of the Fred Harvey company in the early 1900's. Mona Mesereau, a spokesperson for Xanterra, says that nearly one million riders have made the trip, and that up to 40 people per day now ride mules into the canyon.

By contrast, in 2008 the park reported 87,981 overnight hiking trips on park trails, along with a small army of hikers who made shorter day trips. That's a lot of people on the trail in some rugged terrain. Both hikers and mule riders should be thankful for the availability of those helicopters for the small percentage of cases when something does go awry, and for rescuers trained to perform those tricky short-haul operations. The alternative—a long and grueling carryout by litter—is hard on both victims and rescue team members, and still must be used at times when weather, darkness or other factors means a helicopter isn't available.

Comments

In 1998, me,the wife and 2 sons, ages 16 and 13, made the day trip on the mules to Plateau Point. The 13 yr old was freaking out on the way down but he made it. Although we felt safe on the mules, it did cause some anxious moments, as it should have.

On the way down right before one of those 180 switch backs, my mule stumbled, went down to his knees, and then back up. It bout gave me the Big One, but we all made it and had a wonderful time. We still have our certificates that shows we made it down on the mules.

11 years later we still talk about the trip. Unbelieveable.

my wife was below the area where the mule stumbled - she saw the helicopter etc. but she said she heard that there were 3 kids that jumped from a bridge into the river earlier in the week or last week maybe and died - is that true? just curious.
thanks

Anonymous -

Sadly, it's true that three young men jumped into the river on Thursday, April 30, with tragic results. That incident was covered in a separate story in the Traveler which has now dropped off the home page, so I didn't mention it again here.

That search and recovery mission began on the days between the two described in the above story about the hiker and mule rider, illustrating the demanding job rangers have at Grand Canyon - and many other parks.

Do you know what happened to the mule that fell on the woman on May 4, 2009? I have not seen anything regarding injuries to the mules. My sister and I rode to Phantom Ranch on May 12, 2009 and had a fabulous time. We did learn quickly to let the mules do their job. Thanks for any update you can provide.

No, and I haven't heard if the woman died. I heard she pulled the mule over after it stumbled. Anyone know anything?

regarding the mule accident on may 5, 2009: i am the woman who went over the cliff with the mule. he tripped and fell. i did not pull him over. there are witnesses to that fact.
i broke several bones. e.g, ankle, leg, ribs, wrist, shoulder and fractured c1 and c2.
i am blessed that there was a retired emt person and a wilderness first responder on the trail. they stabelize my neck and other various injuries. i practically fell at thier feet!
i was at flagstaff medical center for 9 days, then flew to a rehab facility in california.
the short haul rescue and subsequent medical care at both facilities was amazing. following a lot of physical and occupational therapy i am blessed to be up and around again. are things back to normal? no. will they ever be? i hope so.
i too would like to know what has happened to the mule. in my opinion it was not the mules fault that he went down.

Cindy H--

Glad you are recovering!

Me and my father rode the mules to the bottom a couple of years ago. It was the most terrifying and unpleasant experience of my life...I would never recommend it to my worst ennemy. My father's mule fell and slammed him into the side of the canyon...causing a deep cut over his eye. The rangers had to come and tend to him. My mule stumbled also but I held on for dear life. It is a miracle nobody has died on the mules. In my opinion it is only a matter of time.

I went down in 2008. My two sons walked down at the same time. Is it painful and somewhat dangerous to take the mules down. Yes it is. But I could never have walked up [I'm 70]. I would do it again any time. Can we always avoid danger in our lifes? And is what is the point of avoiding danger?
My mule tried to buck me as we were going along the river near the end of the trip down. I held on . Quite an experience. I have an adversion to heights which was of course extremely hightened as the mules slowly went around hairpin turns, and they always walk at the outer edge. It would have been a great view if I could have looked. Surprisingly, my sons didn't hardly notice the hairpin turns since they kept to the inside of the 3' wide trail and could enjoy the view.
The accomidations at the bottom are just wonderful. They met us with ice water. The meals were great. I wish I could do it again.

I am sure glad you survived---God bless you.

You pried me out of hibernation with this story from '09, Kurt :).
There is a great deal of pride and adventure with the NPS SAR teams at the Canyon with many oweing their lives to their efforts. What isn't usually mentioned for various reasons is how much these mule guides add to the safety of the hikers they come accross on a daily basis. There are many cases that just an engaging word from a guide directed at a backpacker that's in over their heads in one of the most hostile environments brings a positive outcome. From poring ice water over children that have the appearance of boiled lobsters with their parents in the summertime Furnace to reefing up a hiker hanging over the edge, clinging to a Gamble Oak limb over very serious exposure are just two of the many situations that guides deal with on occasion in support of everyone on the trails besides their responsibilities toward their riders. Sharing the trails, the responsibilities and the Canyon effects, whether riding mules or backpacking is one of the premier lifetime experiences for many willing to make the effort. Thank you NPS SAR and Canyon Wranglers !

My wife and I as well as my twin 13 year old boys and 9 year old daughter took the one day trip on the mules in October 2008. After booking the trip I watched videos of the mules on Youtube. When we did the trip I was first very apprehensive about the safety of my children but they handled it with ease. It was scary but I placed all of my trust in the mules. They knew what they were doing. Im from Australia and I have recommeded the mule trip to all of my friends planning a trip the the USA. Loved it and I would do it again if I return to the US.